Over a Year After Scott Peterson Was Denied New Trial the Innocence Project Is Stepping In

UPDATE: More than a year after Scott Peterson was denied a new trial, the Innocence Project is taking on his case.

According to ABC News, the Innocence Project believes there is evidence that proves Scott did not kill his wife and unborn child in 2022, a crime he was convicted of in 2004. Now the group “is seeking new evidence from the original trial.”

As new court filings obtained by ABC News revealed, attorneys for the LA Innocence Project believe “Scott Peterson’s state and federal constitutional rights were violated, including a ‘claim of actual innocence that is supported by newly discovered evidence.'”

Further, Paula Mitchell, the director of the LA Innocence Project, says her investigation showed “deficiencies” in Peterson’s case, adding that she came across “‘numerous witnesses’ who have expressed hesitation or ‘outright unwillingness’ to provide information due to the high-profile nature of the case.”

Now, Peterson’s attorneys are claiming that several pieces of evidence cannot be located. As ABC News reports, the lost items include:

“…Evidence from the investigations into a December 2002 burglary of a home across the street from the Petersons’ in Modesto in Stanislaus County, Laci Peterson’s missing Croton watch, and a van fire in the Airport District on Dec. 25, 2002, according to the filings. They are also seeking documents from interviews with several witnesses.”

Scott Peterson, who murdered his wife and unborn child in 2002, was denied a new trial on Tuesday after Superior Court Judge Anne-Christine Massullo ruled there was no juror misconduct during his original trial in 2004. Peterson is currently serving a life sentence in prison at Mule Creek State Prison.

The decision comes after Peterson’s legal team argued he wasn’t given a fair trial due to a tainted jury. The juror was Richelle Nice and she was accused of withholding details about an incident in 2000 where she filed a restraining order against her boyfriend’s ex, citing her unborn child’s safety as the reason. 

Peterson’s legal team claimed that Nice was biased because of her experience with threats against an unborn child. The jury eventually reached a guilty verdict, convicting Peterson of first-degree murder (for killing his pregnant wife, Laci Peterson) and second-degree murder (for killing his unborn child, Conner). 

RELATED: Megachurch Leader Leticia McCormack in Custody for Abusing, Torturing, and Murdering 11-Year-Old Adopted Daughter

“The court concludes that Juror No.7’s (Nice) responses were not motivated by pre-existing or improper bias against Petitioner (Peterson) but instead were a combination of good faith misunderstanding of the questions and sloppiness in answering,” said Judge Anne-Christine Massullo on December 20th. 

In finding no misconduct on Nice’s part, Massullo was effectively denying Scott Peterson a new trial. His original trial in 2004 landed him on death row after being sentenced to death by lethal injection. He remained on death row until two months ago when he was transferred to Mule Creek State Prison. 

The transfer comes after his original death sentence was overturned in 2020 – his conviction remained, but he would no longer be sentenced to death. In September 2021, Massullo re-sentenced Scott Peterson to life in prison without the possibility of parole. In total, he spent nearly two decades on death row. 

Despite being denied a new trial, this isn’t the end for Peterson – who still has the option of appealing the ruling. That’s not to say it would result in a different outcome, but it’s one of the few things he has control over right now. As for what the future holds for Peterson, he’ll likely remain in prison for the rest of his life.

Laci Peterson’s Family Offers Thoughts on the Latest Scott Peterson Update

Laci Peterson was about to be a mother and was preparing for the Christmas holiday when she disappeared on Christmas Eve. Several months later, the bodies of a baby and recently pregnant mother were found near the San Francisco Bay shore in Richmond’s Point Isabel Regional Shoreline Park.

The bodies were later identified as Laci and her son, Conner – who reportedly died in the uterus and was expelled from the body after being dumped in the bay. Over the past 20 years, her family has been forced to deal with the non-stop trials, hearings, and legal battles that have ensued – which hasn’t been easy.

Now that Scott Peterson is being denied a new trial, Laci’s family can breathe again. “It’s a tremendous relief to everyone who loved Laci. Everyone was so worried that they were going to have to go through the pain of a trial again, and no one wanted to deal with that,” a source close to the family told PEOPLE. 

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE: Father of Athena Strand Files Lawsuit Against FedEx, Big TopSpin, and the Driver Who Murdered Her

“This is the best news we could’ve gotten. It really felt like next year was going to be very difficult, reliving the whole thing yet again. Now that’s not going to happen. This was the best Christmas gift ever,” the source continued, as the family prepares for the 20-year anniversary of their loved one’s death.

About Mamas Uncut

Mamas Uncut is THE online place for moms. We cover the latest about motherhood, parenting, and entertainment as well – all with a mom-focused twist. So if you're looking for parenting advice from real parents, we have plenty of it, all for moms from moms, and also experts. Because, at the end of the day, our mission is focused solely on empowering moms and moms-to-be with the knowledge and answers they’re looking for in one safe space.

Scroll to Top