Magical Tooth Fairy Pillows to Make Her Visits Even More Enchanting

Have you seen Tooth Fairy pillows yet? These charming little pillows make each visit from the Tooth Fairy extra special. Gone are the days of children shoving their teeth under the pillows on their beds and now, they have a cute, specialized pillow to conjure the Tooth Fairy. Many of these dreamy pillows have a cute tooth-shaped appearance and can be personalized with your child’s name which they will love.

Your window for Tooth Fairy visits will pass you by if you’re not careful, so make each moment count with a special pillow as your little one loses their baby teeth. We’ve rounded up ten Tooth Fairy pillow options for you to find the best one for your child. Take a look!

Discover the Sweetest Tooth Fairy Pillows Below!

Personalized Unicorn or Superhero Tooth Fairy Pillow

$23.99 at the time of publication.

These Tooth Fairy pillows are best sellers on Etsy. They come in two options: unicorn or superhero and they are personalized with your child’s name. With their little toothbrush wands, these characters are absolutely adorable.

Crafty Personalized Tooth Fairy Pillow

$14 at the time of publication.

Here’s a personalized Tooth Fairy pillow that comes with several options. You get to choose the color of the pillow and the color of the fairy’s hair. We love the sweet, crafty look of these pillows and we hope you do too!

Sweet Dreams Personalized Tooth Fairy Pillow

$17.99 at the time of publication.

Here’s yet another personalized Tooth Fairy pillow. It’s shaped like an actual fairy which is a winning look. Further, your child’s name can be applied in white ink or in glow-in-the-dark ink to make it even more special. There’s a little pocket for you to slip a surprise into within the tooth element.

Personalized Unicorn Rainbow Tooth Fairy Pillow

$25 at the time of publication.

How precious is the pastel, rainbow, unicorn, tooth fairy pillow? What a dream! This personalized pillow comes with a pocket (behind that Polkadot bit) for you to sneak a special surprise into.

Tiny Plush Tooth Fairy Pillow

$8 at the time of publication.

Are you looking for something that’s cute and small and feels enchanted? Get one of these mini pillows that can be personalized with your child’s name. It contains a tiny little pocket for the Tooth Fairy exchange to happen and you can request to have it with or without a little ribbon for hanging. Choose from a variety of colors to get your kid’s favorite one.

Smiley Tooth Fairy Pillows

$12.90+ at the time of publication.

If you’re looking for something even more personalized for your child, consider these Tooth Fairy pillows that come in a variety of fabrics. Dots, stars, stripes, dinosaurs, and more are all possibilities here. A smiley tooth sits cutely on the front while a pocket on the back will help with the Tooth Fairy’s transaction.

Precious Tooth Fairy Pillows With Personalization and Tooth Receipt

$25.53+ at the time of publication.

Here’s a truly adaptable Tooth Fairy people that comes with tons of options. You get to choose the style of tutu and if you want the tooth pillow with a colorful crown or a crown of flowers. Further, your child’s name can be imprinted on the back of the pillow above a little pocket. It comes with a “receipt” from the Tooth Fairy which makes for a charming keepsake.

Personalized Monogrammed Seersucker Tooth Fairy Pillow

$15 at the time of publication.

Check out these seersucker pillows that come in a variety of colors with a ribbon for hanging to match. You also get to choose from a variety of fonts for your child’s name to be embroidered in. Behind the tooth, you will find a pocket for the Fairy to leave her reward.

Highly Personalized Tooth Fairy Pillow

$23+ at the time of publication.

Okay, so here’s a very cute Tooth Fairy pillow that you can make bespoke for your child. You get to choose the Fairy’s hair and skin color, the color scheme for the pillow (including name and tooth), the ribbon color, and the option to have a tooth chart on the back of the pillow that’s imprinted on top of the pocket. It’s extremely, extremely customizable!

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE: Dr. Anthony Fauci Adorably Reassures 7-Year-Old Ava That the Tooth Fairy Can’t Catch Coronavirus

Simple Yet Cute Tooth Pillow

$18 at the time of publication.

We’re very fond of this simple Tooth Fairy pillow that comes in the shape of a tooth with a little pocket on the right side. Further, you can choose to have the pillow personalized with your child’s name on the back. As with many of these pillows, it comes with a ribbon to hang the pillow on a door handle. Sometimes straightforward is best and this tooth means business!

There you go! Did you find the perfect Tooth Fairy pillow? We certainly hope you found something cute to make the Tooth Fairy’s visit even more special. These pillows offer the perfect little touch of whimsy that your little one will definitely fall in love with.

Mamas Uncut is a participant in multiple affiliate programs, including Skimlinks, ShareASale, Commission Junction, and the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Mamas Uncut may earn a percentage of revenue generated from purchases made via the links in this post.